01. Rankings

Full toothpaste rankings

All 32 brands, ordered by overall score. Filter by fluoride, hydroxyapatite, SLS, kid-safe, awards, and price, or sort the table to match how you shop.

Showing 32 of 32 brands

Rank	Name	Score	Award	Fluoride	HAp	SLS	$/oz	Verdict
01	KlyyrOne+	92.8	Best overall	No	10% (nano & micro)	No	$3.06	Best overall for clean-ingredient remineralization
02	FyggNano-Hydroxyapatite Toothpaste	87.5	Best for kids	No	About 3.1% nanoXIM nHAp (brand-stated)	No	$3.50	Best kid-forward hydroxyapatite experience
03	BokaEla Mint Nano-Hydroxyapatite Toothpaste	87.0	n/a	No	Nano-hydroxyapatite (dose not prominently stated as %)	No	$3.00	Excellent clean nHAp option with standout taste
04	RiseWellMineral Toothpaste	85.8	n/a	No	Hydroxyapatite (concentration not always listed as a single %)	No	$3.82	Strong mineral formula for fluoride-free households
05	DavidsPremium Natural Toothpaste / Hydroxi	85.3	Best zero-waste	No	Available in Hydroxi nHAp versions; classic line may rely on other minerals	No	$1.90	Best packaging story in clean toothpaste
06	WellnesseWhitening Toothpaste	82.2	n/a	No	Micro-hydroxyapatite (brand-stated)	No	$3.75	Solid clean pick if you avoid glycerin
07	HelloAntiplaque + Whitening Fluoride Toothpaste	78.3	Best budget natural	Yes	n/a	No	$1.25	Best budget-friendly natural-leaning pickup
08	BiteToothpaste Bits	74.9	n/a	No	Nano-hydroxyapatite in some formulas	No	$4.80	Innovative format; verify active and foam expectations
09	SquigleEnamel Saver	74.1	n/a	Yes	n/a	No	$3.00	Strong SLS-free fluoride pick for sensitive mouths
10	Tom's of MaineAnticavity Fluoride Toothpaste (various)	73.7	n/a	Yes	n/a	No	$1.38	Familiar natural brand; read for carrageenan and SKU variance
11	SprinJeneNatural Toothpaste (fluoride and fluoride-free options)	73.7	n/a	Yes	n/a	No	$2.00	Underrated natural line with a zinc story
12	Burt's BeesNatural Toothpaste (fluoride options)	73.3	n/a	Yes	n/a	No	$1.17	Easy natural-aisle pickup with real fluoride options
13	CloSYSFluoride Toothpaste (Ultra Sensitive / Gentle Mint)	72.0	n/a	Yes	n/a	No	$2.35	Excellent gentle option when foam and burn are the problem
14	Dr. Bronner'sAll-One Toothpaste	70.9	n/a	No	n/a	No	$1.40	Cleanest-looking label, weakest enamel-active story
15	LumineuxWhitening Toothpaste	70.7	n/a	No	n/a	No	$3.20	Whitening-focused clean brand; verify enamel-active expectations
16	RADIUSOrganic Gel Toothpaste	70.7	n/a	No	n/a	No	$2.67	Strong organic credentials; modest remineralization story
17	NativeFluoride-Free Toothpaste	70.3	n/a	No	n/a	No	$2.00	Approachable clean paste; light on remineralizing actives
18	TwiceOral Wellness Toothpaste	70.1	n/a	Yes	n/a	Yes	$3.53	Premium fluoride lifestyle paste with strong flavor appeal
19	Schmidt'sNatural Toothpaste	69.8	n/a	No	n/a	No	$1.28	Clean-leaning everyday paste without enamel-active leadership
20	GeorganicsMineral Toothpaste / Coconut Oil Toothpaste	69.7	n/a	No	n/a	No	$2.94	Eco-minded natural paste; niche texture and active profile
21	QuipAnticavity Toothpaste	68.8	n/a	Yes	n/a	Yes	$1.25	Convenient fluoride paste; conventional formula under clean branding
22	Uncle Harry'sNatural Toothpaste Remineralizing	68.5	n/a	No	n/a	No	$3.00	Ultra-natural jar paste for purists who accept the texture tradeoff
23	HimalayaComplete Care Toothpaste / Botanique	68.2	n/a	No	n/a	No	$0.95	Affordable botanical paste; modest modern remineralization profile
24	JasonPowersmile / Sea Fresh Toothpaste	68.1	n/a	No	n/a	No	$1.08	Serviceable natural standby without modern HAp leadership
25	Desert EssenceTea Tree Oil Toothpaste / Natural Toothpaste	68.0	n/a	No	n/a	No	$0.96	Familiar natural-aisle paste with a tea tree niche
26	RedmondEarthpaste	67.4	n/a	No	n/a	No	$2.50	True minimalist texture; niche daily experience
27	SensodynePronamel / Repair & Protect (representative)	66.2	Best for sensitivity	Yes	n/a	Yes	$1.75	Best mainstream option when sensitivity is the main problem
28	CrestPro-Health / 3D White (representative fluoride paste)	65.0	Best fluoride option	Yes	n/a	Yes	$1.22	Best widely available fluoride workhorse
29	BioteneFresh Mint Gentle Formula Toothpaste	64.7	Best for dry mouth	Yes	n/a	Yes	$1.63	Best mainstream pick when dry mouth is the main problem
30	ColgateTotal / Cavity Protection (representative)	63.4	n/a	Yes	n/a	Yes	$1.12	Reliable mainstream fluoride; weak clean-label fit
31	Arm & HammerAdvance White / PeroxiCare (representative)	61.1	n/a	Yes	n/a	Yes	$0.93	Budget baking-soda option; conventional additives remain
32	MarvisClassic Strong Mint (and flavor collection)	60.2	n/a	Yes	n/a	Yes	$3.16	Best-in-class flavor theater; conventional clean-label fit is weak

0192.8
Klyyr
One+
Best overall
Best overall for clean-ingredient remineralization
Fluoride
No
HAp
10% (nano & micro)
SLS
No
$/oz
$3.06
NET WT 4 OZ
0287.5
Fygg
Nano-Hydroxyapatite Toothpaste
Best for kids
Best kid-forward hydroxyapatite experience
Fluoride
No
HAp
About 3.1% nanoXIM nHAp (brand-stated)
SLS
No
$/oz
$3.50
NET WT 4 OZ
0387.0
Boka
Ela Mint Nano-Hydroxyapatite Toothpaste
Excellent clean nHAp option with standout taste
Fluoride
No
HAp
Nano-hydroxyapatite (dose not prominently stated as %)
SLS
No
$/oz
$3.00
NET WT 3.4 OZ
0485.8
RiseWell
Mineral Toothpaste
Strong mineral formula for fluoride-free households
Fluoride
No
HAp
Hydroxyapatite (concentration not always listed as a single %)
SLS
No
$/oz
$3.82
NET WT 5.25 OZ
0585.3
Davids
Premium Natural Toothpaste / Hydroxi
Best zero-waste
Best packaging story in clean toothpaste
Fluoride
No
HAp
Available in Hydroxi nHAp versions; classic line may rely on other minerals
SLS
No
$/oz
$1.90
NET WT 4 OZ
0682.2
Wellnesse
Whitening Toothpaste
Solid clean pick if you avoid glycerin
Fluoride
No
HAp
Micro-hydroxyapatite (brand-stated)
SLS
No
$/oz
$3.75
NET WT 4 OZ
0778.3
Hello
Antiplaque + Whitening Fluoride Toothpaste
Best budget natural
Best budget-friendly natural-leaning pickup
Fluoride
Yes
HAp
n/a
SLS
No
$/oz
$1.25
NET WT 2.5 OZ
0874.9
Bite
Toothpaste Bits
Innovative format; verify active and foam expectations
Fluoride
No
HAp
Nano-hydroxyapatite in some formulas
SLS
No
$/oz
$4.80
NET WT 4 OZ
0974.1
Squigle
Enamel Saver
Strong SLS-free fluoride pick for sensitive mouths
Fluoride
Yes
HAp
n/a
SLS
No
$/oz
$3.00
NET WT 4 OZ
1073.7
Tom's of Maine
Anticavity Fluoride Toothpaste (various)
Familiar natural brand; read for carrageenan and SKU variance
Fluoride
Yes
HAp
n/a
SLS
No
$/oz
$1.38
NET WT 3.5 OZ
1173.7
SprinJene
Natural Toothpaste (fluoride and fluoride-free options)
Underrated natural line with a zinc story
Fluoride
Yes
HAp
n/a
SLS
No
$/oz
$2.00
NET WT 4.7 OZ
1273.3
Burt's Bees
Natural Toothpaste (fluoride options)
Easy natural-aisle pickup with real fluoride options
Fluoride
Yes
HAp
n/a
SLS
No
$/oz
$1.17
NET WT 3.4 OZ
1372.0
CloSYS
Fluoride Toothpaste (Ultra Sensitive / Gentle Mint)
Excellent gentle option when foam and burn are the problem
Fluoride
Yes
HAp
n/a
SLS
No
$/oz
$2.35
NET WT 5 OZ
1470.9
Dr. Bronner's
All-One Toothpaste
Cleanest-looking label, weakest enamel-active story
Fluoride
No
HAp
n/a
SLS
No
$/oz
$1.40
NET WT 3.75 OZ
1570.7
Lumineux
Whitening Toothpaste
Whitening-focused clean brand; verify enamel-active expectations
Fluoride
No
HAp
n/a
SLS
No
$/oz
$3.20
NET WT 3 OZ
1670.7
RADIUS
Organic Gel Toothpaste
Strong organic credentials; modest remineralization story
Fluoride
No
HAp
n/a
SLS
No
$/oz
$2.67
NET WT 4 OZ
1770.3
Native
Fluoride-Free Toothpaste
Approachable clean paste; light on remineralizing actives
Fluoride
No
HAp
n/a
SLS
No
$/oz
$2.00
NET WT 3.4 OZ
1870.1
Twice
Oral Wellness Toothpaste
Premium fluoride lifestyle paste with strong flavor appeal
Fluoride
Yes
HAp
n/a
SLS
Yes
$/oz
$3.53
NET WT 4.7 OZ
1969.8
Schmidt's
Natural Toothpaste
Clean-leaning everyday paste without enamel-active leadership
Fluoride
No
HAp
n/a
SLS
No
$/oz
$1.28
NET WT 3.4 OZ
2069.7
Georganics
Mineral Toothpaste / Coconut Oil Toothpaste
Eco-minded natural paste; niche texture and active profile
Fluoride
No
HAp
n/a
SLS
No
$/oz
$2.94
NET WT 4 OZ
2168.8
Quip
Anticavity Toothpaste
Convenient fluoride paste; conventional formula under clean branding
Fluoride
Yes
HAp
n/a
SLS
Yes
$/oz
$1.25
NET WT 3 OZ
2268.5
Uncle Harry's
Natural Toothpaste Remineralizing
Ultra-natural jar paste for purists who accept the texture tradeoff
Fluoride
No
HAp
n/a
SLS
No
$/oz
$3.00
NET WT 5.29 OZ
2368.2
Himalaya
Complete Care Toothpaste / Botanique
Affordable botanical paste; modest modern remineralization profile
Fluoride
No
HAp
n/a
SLS
No
$/oz
$0.95
NET WT 6 OZ
2468.1
Jason
Powersmile / Sea Fresh Toothpaste
Serviceable natural standby without modern HAp leadership
Fluoride
No
HAp
n/a
SLS
No
$/oz
$1.08
NET WT 6.25 OZ
2568.0
Desert Essence
Tea Tree Oil Toothpaste / Natural Toothpaste
Familiar natural-aisle paste with a tea tree niche
Fluoride
No
HAp
n/a
SLS
No
$/oz
$0.96
NET WT 4 OZ
2667.4
Redmond
Earthpaste
True minimalist texture; niche daily experience
Fluoride
No
HAp
n/a
SLS
No
$/oz
$2.50
NET WT 4 OZ
2766.2
Sensodyne
Pronamel / Repair & Protect (representative)
Best for sensitivity
Best mainstream option when sensitivity is the main problem
Fluoride
Yes
HAp
n/a
SLS
Yes
$/oz
$1.75
NET WT 4.1 OZ
2865.0
Crest
Pro-Health / 3D White (representative fluoride paste)
Best fluoride option
Best widely available fluoride workhorse
Fluoride
Yes
HAp
n/a
SLS
Yes
$/oz
$1.22
NET WT 4.3 OZ
2964.7
Biotene
Fresh Mint Gentle Formula Toothpaste
Best for dry mouth
Best mainstream pick when dry mouth is the main problem
Fluoride
Yes
HAp
n/a
SLS
Yes
$/oz
$1.63
NET WT 4 OZ
3063.4
Colgate
Total / Cavity Protection (representative)
Reliable mainstream fluoride; weak clean-label fit
Fluoride
Yes
HAp
n/a
SLS
Yes
$/oz
$1.12
NET WT 4.3 OZ
3161.1
Arm & Hammer
Advance White / PeroxiCare (representative)
Budget baking-soda option; conventional additives remain
Fluoride
Yes
HAp
n/a
SLS
Yes
$/oz
$0.93
NET WT 3.8 OZ
3260.2
Marvis
Classic Strong Mint (and flavor collection)
Best-in-class flavor theater; conventional clean-label fit is weak
Fluoride
Yes
HAp
n/a
SLS
Yes
$/oz
$3.16

Klyyr

Fygg

Boka

RiseWell

Davids

Wellnesse

Hello

Bite

Squigle

Tom's of Maine

SprinJene

Burt's Bees

CloSYS

Dr. Bronner's

Lumineux

RADIUS

Native

Twice

Schmidt's

Georganics

Quip

Uncle Harry's

Himalaya

Jason

Desert Essence

Redmond

Sensodyne

Crest

Biotene

Colgate

Arm & Hammer

Marvis